A constitutional attorney has submitted an emergency motion aiming to compel the newly elected Parti Québécois government to pledge loyalty to King Charles.
The request for a temporary injunction was lodged in Quebec Superior Court by the Public Interest Litigation Institute, spearheaded by its founder, Lawrence David.
David asserted that political parties, “irrespective of their affiliations,” are “not permitted to disregard the laws that govern all democratic entities in Canada.”
“That is exactly why we are taking a stand,” David, who serves as a law professor at the University of Ottawa, mentioned in a recent interview.
“We are utilizing the legal framework, which is the purpose of the legal system, to guarantee that … governments adhere to the laws that apply to them.”
The injunction seeks the court’s intervention to immediately annul a 2022 provincial statute that rendered the oath to the monarch optional for members of the National Assembly. David has previously initiated a lawsuit in August concerning the same issue.
This latest action follows the election win by the sovereignist Parti Québécois on Monday.
Paul St-Pierre Plamondon, the premier-designate, has committed to reducing funding for the office of Quebec’s lieutenant-governor within his first 100 days in office, as part of an initiative to “abolish” the monarchy in the province.
The legal document contends that if the newly elected MNAs decline to swear the oath to the King, they would not meet the constitutional requirements to hold seats in the legislature.
The lawsuit cautions that any legislation enacted by an improperly assembled body—particularly any law aimed at eliminating the lieutenant governor—would be invalid, leading to an “unprecedented legal crisis.”
A representative from the PQ has not provided a response to a request for comments as of Wednesday.
The injunction will be presented in a Montreal courtroom on Friday morning. If the injunction is approved, MNAs would be legally obligated to take the oath before assuming their roles. The National Assembly is set to reconvene on November 17.
Karine Millaire, an expert in constitutional law and an associate professor at the Université de Montréal, noted via email that the “injunction was anticipated given the ongoing constitutional challenge regarding the 2022 law in court.”
Addressing the emergency injunction, Millaire commented that the onus will be “on the applicants” to demonstrate that their case presents substantial legal arguments.
Ultimately, she expressed in an email, “these discussions about the monarchy could potentially lead to a constitutional crisis, which is something we do not desire.”
